2019-2021 Establish QA System for Teachers Training, Croatian Agency for Teachers Training (Croatia)
The Croatian Agency for Teachers Training has requested technical assistance to establish a quality assurance system for its training system and also make an assessment of their online training programmes so far. BH Associates is working in partnership with the Institute of Education, Dublin City University, Ireland. This is an EU Structural Reform Support Service (SRSS) project.
2019-2020 Maynooth University (Ireland)
To provide consultancy services to, inter alia, the following key areas:
Governance (compliance and effectiveness reviews)
Strategy (planning, structural reviews)
Fundraising (alumni relations, feasibility studies)
Student marketing and recruitment (recruitment strategies, student communication)
BH is undertaking this work in partnership with Dr Graham Love, Mazars Ireland.
2019 Honourable Society of King’s Inns (Ireland)
Review of the quality assurance processes in the Honourable Society of King’s Inns, their consistency with the processes required by Quality and Qualifications Ireland and best practice in institutions internationally for the education and training of lawyers.
2019 - 2020: Independent Commission. “The College of the Future” (UK)
BH Associates has been appointed to the Commission on The College of the Future, which is funded by the Gatsby Foundation, UK. The aim is to review and make recommendations regarding the future of Further Education in the UK. The Commission aims to:
To shape the pivotal role colleges should play over the next decade in every locality acrossthe four nations in meeting the skills needs of the rapidly changing labour market and helping to develop a culture of lifelong learning in all of our communities;
To build an understanding and support among stakeholders – employer organisations, unions and the public at large - of the critical and distinctive function of colleges in delivering high-quality professional and technical education and skills, embedding their role as anchor community assets, central to inclusive economic prosperity and social fairness;
To describe the space which colleges can inhabit in relation to other education institutions, public bodies and employers, with a particular focus on place-based approaches to meeting all of the diverse needs of our communities.
2019 Republic of Tajikistan, Higher Education Project (HEP)
BH Associates is providing expert advice and support for the assessment of project proposals under the Competitive Grants Program. HEP is implemented by the Ministry of Education and Science of Republic of Tajikistan (MOES), with the support of the World Bank.
2018-2019: Design a Performance Framework for the Dublin Institute of Advanced Studies (DIAS, Ireland)
This project involves two inter-related aspects. 1) Design of a Performance Framework for DIAS, appropriate to an Institute of Advanced Studies (IAS), which can support the quinquennial external review process, and provide a template for reporting annually as appropriate for DIAS. 2) Design of the Terms of Reference (ToR) for the quinquennial School Review. Both tasks will be conducted cognisant of the broader context of international best practice and national objectives for research and higher education. The overall purpose is to strengthen the quality enhancement culture within DIAS, to assess the quality of the research activity, outcomes and impact in the context of international standards and the DIAS Strategy for 2018-2022, to identify potential for further developments and improvement, and to make recommendations.
Previous Projects (selected)
2018: Review of Options for a Future National Approach to Journal Subscriptions and e-Resources (HEA, Ireland)
This is a strategic review of options for a future national approach to journal subscriptions and e-resources, by academics, researchers and others in Ireland. The review is being conducted in the context of increasing publisher costs and growing support for open science. The Strategic Review seeks to understand usage, and opportunities and challenges of accessing and using e-journals etc., to set out best practice in the provision of national research e-library services, and to propose strategic options for the future. The ambition is that IReL will grow to become a national research e-library, and the Strategic Review will be an important step in translating this ambition into a realisable and sustainable strategy.
2018: Comparative Assessment of University Rankings and Education Indicators. Analysing and Complementing U-Multirank (EU)
Undertake review of global rankings, and identify alternatives indicators to measure teaching and learning/education quality – e.g. a feasibility assessment for the development of new indicators. The project is being undertaken on behalf of the European Commission.
2018: Sorbonne University, Abu Dhabi
BH Associates was involved in two inter-related projects for the Sorbonne University UAD (SUAD). Project 1 concerns designing a new organisational structure, with particular focus on research support office and graduate studies, and including an assessment of staffing needs. Project 2 concerns a review of programme relevance with respect to future skills needs in the region. The projects involved, inter alia, the following tasks and outputs:
· Review and analysis of the organisational structure, and drawing on an extensive reservoir of experience and practice at universities around the world, the objectives is to identify optimal, and optional, organisational structures and to deliver these functions;
· Review and assess the current operational efficiency, in terms of staffing and processes;
· Review and assess UAE’s higher education, labour market and economic policies and plans and how these translate in terms of required university degrees and skills;
· Research and analysis of international models of alignment between academic programs and skills needed for a local economy including labour market activation programs;
· Provide advice on applicability to the environment in which SUAD operates;
· Review and analysis of academic programmes, with assessment of alignment with local skills needs and opportunities.
2018: Policy Options to Support Welsh Universities' Delivery of Civic Mission (WCPP, Wales)
Undertake Review and Provide Expert Advice for the Welsh Centre for Public Policy, and the Welsh Government. The project is looking at policy options to support and encourage higher education institutions' social and economic contributions, regionally and locally, as part of their civic mission. The project is being conducted in partnership with Professor John Goddard, Newcastle University, UK.
Maximising universities’ civic contribution. A policy paper is available here.
Response by Education Secretary Kirsty Williams to the report is available.
2018: Review and Advice on the Munster Technological University application
BH Associates was asked to review the application, to provide feedback and to make recommendations on the MTU Submission Document for Technological University status.
2018: Risk Management Identification, Advisory and Mitigation Services in relation to the specific proposal to create a multi-campus Technological University of the South East.
Provide analysis and identification of issues with respect to the merger between Waterford Institute of Technology and Carlow Institute of Technology with respect to the proposal to create a Technological University of the South East per the Technological Universities Act, 2018.
This review is conducted in association with Prospectus Management Consultants.
2018: Review of HEA and IRC Regulatory Frameworks (Higher Education Authority & Irish Research Council, Ireland)
In the context of a forthcoming review of the legislation of the Higher Education Authority, this review will identify how the regulatory framework for the governance and funding of Higher Education could be developed, strengthened and made more effective in light of national and international regulatory experience.
2018: Holmes Institute, Australia and Ireland
Provide advice regarding establishing higher education opportunities in Ireland, including quality assurance guidance.
2018: Higher Education for Smart Specialisation (EU)
Contribution to Handbook on Higher Education and Smart Specialisation, for the Joint Research Centre, Directorate for Growth and Innovation, Unit B3: Territorial Development, European Commission
2017-2018: Review of Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education (QAA), UK
This is an ENQA-coordinated review of the Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education (QAA) (http://www.qaa.ac.uk/), an ENQA member since 2000, which is now applying for renewal of ENQA membership.
Member of Review Panel.
2018: From Charter to Framework: The Case for Higher Education Provision in Kilkenny, Ireland
Kilkenny County Council engaged BH Associates to explore the case for a substantial higher education provision in Kilkenny city to support the social and economic development of the city, county, and region through the provision, attraction, and retention of graduates with high-level skills. The report was launched by Minister of State for Higher Education Mary Mitchell O’Connor.
The Report found:
· There is a convincing educational, social and economic case for locating tertiary/higher education and training provision in Kilkenny with the proposal aligning well with government policy across education – including meeting growing demand and drawing on policy objectives for technological universities.
· The proposal also aligns well with regional policy, especially as regards providing counter-weights to Dublin, based on making the South-East region more attractive than it currently is.
· The inclusion of Kilkenny as a campus of a multi-campus technological university in the South-East would enhance the development and impact of the university.
· Provision should leverage off regional/local expertise and strengths (in craft/design, agriculture, and/or animation – as well as history/culture and heritage/tourism) in order to establish a national centre of excellence so that it strengthens the region’s attractiveness nationally and internationally and builds sustainability.
· Smart specialisation strategies provide opportunities to deepen partnerships between PACE (agri-tech) and NDIH (design) with enterprise and regional authorities to contribute to, and strengthen, innovation and regional development.
2018 Review of College Awareness Week Programme (HEA, Ireland)
A review of, and report on, the College Awareness Week Programme– a major programme of the Irish Government relating to equity of access to higher education. A key focus of the review was to establish the extent to which CAW delivers on national equity of access policy goals and the extent to which it operates as a shared initiative across the higher education and further education system. Key considerations are to:
1 Assess the impact of CAW for (i) members of target groups in the National Access Plan 2015-2019, in particular those from schools and communities who are very under-represented in higher education (ii) other schools, groups and communities
2 Consider how CAW has enhanced the existing access programmes and guidance activities of higher and further education institutions.
3 Review how the structures and objectives of CAW compare to other national campaigns in the higher education sector.
4 Recommend measures for the future arising from the outputs of the above.
2017 - 2018: Mid-Term Review of the Further Education and Training (FET) Strategy, Ireland
The Further Education & Training Strategy, 2014-2019 aims to deliver a higher quality learning experience leading to better outcomes for all those who engage in FET. It presents a roadmap and implementation plan to realise the vision of a world-class integrated system of further education and training in Ireland which will: support economic development; increase social inclusion; and meet the needs of all learners, communities and employers who engage with FET. The FET Strategy is set within a context of Government reform of public services.
This review was conducted with Prospectus Management Consultants.
2017 - 2018: Quality Audit, University of Oulu, Finland
Chairperson, Quality Review of the University of Oulu, organised by the Finnish Education Evaluation Centre (FINEEC).
The principle of enhancement-led evaluation is a strong tradition in Finnish evaluation practice. The goal is to help HEIs recognise the strengths, good practices and areas in need of development in their operations. The institutions are supported in their efforts to reach their strategic objectives and in directing future development activities in order to create a framework for the institutions continuous development. Audits are implemented in four stages. First, the HEI carries out a self-evaluation and prepares the audit material. Next, a team of experts examines the material and then visits the institution. Finally, the results of the audit are published in the form of a report.
2017-2018: Performance funding in Cypriot Universities
Provision of expertise to the Ministry of Education and Culture, Cyprus, on the introduction of performance based funding in public universities in Cyprus, supported by the Structural Reform Support Service of the Commission of the European Union.
2017: Holmes Institute, Australia and Ireland
Review and advice provided regarding opportunities for English-language provision in Ireland, in the context of BREXIT and increasing demand by international students.
2017: IMF/EC Technical Assistance
Member of a joint International Monetary Fund/European Commission team providing technical assistance to the Government of Slovakia in support of a review of public expenditure in a number of areas of activity, including education.
2015 - 2016: Oversight of Post-Compulsory Education, Wales
Review conducted of post-compulsory education in Wales, with special reference to the future role and function of the Higher Education Funding Council for Wales (HEFCW). The Terms of Reference included:
A. To review, analyse and document the current arrangements for the oversight of post-compulsory education in Wales, including:
- quality assurance / standards of education and training, and
- management of risk.
B. To advise on the effectiveness of current arrangements for the oversight of post-compulsory education in Wales judged by reference to other UK nations, relevant international comparators and research evidence.
C. To make recommendations for the future oversight of post-compulsory education in Wales with particular reference to the role of the Higher Education Funding Council for Wales and its interface with Estyn.
D. To indicate whether there may be a need for legislation and new or reformed institutional arrangements to take forward future arrangements proposed in the light of this evaluation.
Welsh Government announced acceptance of the recommendations made in the report. 31 January 2017.
2016 - 2017: Government Accountability Office (GAO), Higher Education Accreditation, Washington DC.
Expert Opinion provided for US government review of accreditation practices and procedures in the US and internationally. Ellen Hazelkorn was also a member of the committee on “Quality Higher Education: What Does It Mean, How Is It Measured, And Who Decides?”, National Academy of Sciences, Washington, DC, US, 2015-2016
2015 - 2016: Evaluation & Development of Higher Education Ranking System, Ministry of Education, UAE
Review and assessment undertaken to assess the effectiveness of the proposed ranking system in the UAE, the strengths and weaknesses of the ranking methodologies, the weights assigned to different indicators and their impact on driving the overall quality of higher education in the UAE.
The examination included the following:
• Assessment of the current environment of higher education in the UAE and the purpose behind the development of a national ranking system for universities and colleges.
• Examination of the proposed ranking system of higher education, its methodology, indicators and weights, and its effectiveness in improving the quality of the outcomes of the universities and colleges and their contribution to the economic and cultural development of the nation.
• Assess the validity and reliability of the proposed ranking system in measuring the contribution made by a variety of institutions (research and non-research based) of higher education with different educational missions.
• Provide benchmarking and alignment analysis of the proposed UAE higher education ranking system against the best in the world and countries with similar higher education context.
• Provide recommendations for improving the methodology, indicators and the weights given to various categories measuring the performance of higher education institutions.
• Provide an action plan to phase in the implementation of the newly established higher education ranking system in the UAE by an independent agency.
2015 Finnish Review of Higher Education, Ministry of Education and Culture, Finland
Chairperson of the International Panel of Experts.
The International Panel was asked to review the Finnish Higher Education System in order to analyze its strengths and weaknesses and identify proposals to improve the higher education system and strengthen Finland’s innovation system.
·What are the main characteristics of the Finnish Higher Education (HE) system and how has the system developed over the last decade? How has the system dealt with the major policy trends?
How does the Finnish HE system perform in terms of the three missions (education, research and utilization)? How does the Finnish system score compare to other European countries? In which domains it is leading and in which domains it is under-performing?
What are the (perceived) bottlenecks in the system? What are the (perceived) strengths of the system?
Is the Finnish HE system “future proof”? What are the major trends and (internal and external) developments that will influence the Finnish HE system? In which way will it influence the system? What is the appropriate way to react to these developments?
What is the way forward for the Finnish HE system? Which development proposals should be implemented
2013 - 2014 Strategic Review of the ISAT Alliance (Karelia University of Applied Sciences and Savonia University of Applied Sciences), Finland
Strategic review undertaken to identify the value-added component of the ISAT Alliance priorities and how the two universities can best benefit from them in terms of RDI, education, and regional development. The objectives of the evaluation were:
To evaluate the implementation of the ISAT strategy with focus on ISAT priorities;
To evaluate the value-added of ISAT priorities
To make recommendations to strengthen the ISAT Alliances, and regional engagement.
2010 - 2011 Assessment of “Faculty for the Future Fellows” Programme, Schlumberger Foundation, Paris
Expert Assessment of the Admissions Criteria and Procedures for the Graduate Research and Post-Doctoral Research Scholarship Programme and to make recommendations to improve the system so that it best meets the objectives of the programme.
The programme aims to support women in STEM disciplines from emerging and developing countries engaged in post-graduate studies. Fellows are expected to return to their home countries after completion of their studies to contribute to economic, social and technological advancement by strengthening the STEM teaching and research faculties of their home institutions, and also to pursue positions in the public sector where their newly acquired technical and scientific skills can help provide evidence-based support for STEM policy making. In so doing, they become powerful role models and help to inspire other girls and women to pursue scientific careers.